revised
and reprinted with kind permission from Paul Fisette
Using
span tables to size joists and rafters is a straight-forward process
when you understand the structural principles that govern their
use.
by
Paul Fisette
© 1997
Wood is naturally
engineered to serve as a structural material: The stem of a tree
is fastened to the earth at its base (foundation), supports the
weight of its branches (column) and bends as it is loaded by the
wind (cantilever beam). A complete analysis of wood's mechanical
properties is complex, but understanding a few basics of lumber
strength will allow you to size joists and rafters with the use
of span tables.
Let's start
by taking a broad view. The structural goal of a house is to safely
transfer building loads (weights) through the foundation to the
supporting soil. Remember when your science teacher said: every
action has an opposite and equal reaction? Well every building load
has an equal "reaction load". If, when the loads of the house are
combined, the house weighs more than the soil can support - the
house will sink until it reaches a point at which the soil can support
the load. This article will focus on how simple beams like joists
and rafters react to loading.
Residential
Loading
The house acts
as a structural system resisting dead loads (weight of materials),
live loads (weights imposed by use and occupancy), like snow
loads and wind loads. Beams, studs, joists and rafters act as a
structural skeleton and must be strong enough and stiff enough to
resist these loads.
Strength and
stiffness are equally important. For example, first-floor ceiling
plaster would crack as occupants walked across a second-floor bedroom
that was framed with bouncy floor joists. Perhaps the joists were
strong enough if they didn't break! But lack of stiffness leads
to costly problems.
Stiffness of
structural members is limited by maximum allowable deflection. In
other words, how much a joist or rafter bends under the maximum
expected load. Only live loads are used to calculate design values
for stiffness.
Maximum deflection
limits are set by building codes. They are expressed as a fraction;
clear span in inches (L) over a given number. For example: a floor
joist appropriately selected to span 10 feet with an L/360 limit
will deflect no more than 120"/360 = 1/3 inches under maximum design
loads. Drywall attached to the underside of this system is not expected
to crack when the floor joist system deflects 1/3".
Typical deflection
limits referenced in code books are L/360, L/240 or L/180. These
limits are based on live loads and activities experienced in specific
rooms of a house. Examples of code-prescribed deflection limits
and live load values are:
- Living room floors
L/360 & 40 psf
- Bedrooms and habitable
attic floors L/360 & 30 psf
- Attic floors with
limited storage L/240 & 10 psf.
Strength of a material is
obviously important. Joists, and rafters must be strong enough not
to break when loaded. Unlike stiffness, live loads and dead loads
are added together to determine minimum design values for strength.
To determine
the dead load value for a given floor or roof system, the weight
of all permanently installed materials in a given component are
added together. For a floor system you can find the individual weights
of drywall, strapping, floor joists, subfloor, underlayment and
carpet in an architectural handbook like Architectural Graphic Standards.
But for most cases there is a cookbook solution. Simply reference
Span Tables
for Joists and Rafters published by the American
Forest & Paper Association's (AF&PA), American
Wood Council (AWC). AF&PA's Appendix A lists a variety of
live and dead load combinations for floors, ceilings and rafters.
For example, Appendix A indicates that one type of clay tile roof
system has a live load value of 20 psf and a dead load value of
15 psf.
Factors
That Influence
Many factors
influence how a system responds to loading. It is important to realize
that the way you select and use materials will control costs and
performance.
- Depth of structural
members. Often, 2x10 joists spaced 24-inches o.c. will provide
a stronger and stiffer floor assembly than 2x8 joists of the
same grade and species that are spaced 16-inches o.c.
- E value or modulus
of elasticity of the individual elements. E is a ratio that
relates the amount a given load causes a material to deform.
A material with a higher E value is stiffer. For example: No.2
grade eastern white pine has an E value of 1,100,000 and No.2
hem-fir has an E value of 1,300,000. Hem-fir is a stiffer material.
- Fb value or extreme
fiber stress in bending. Loads cause beams, joists and rafters
to bend. As a beam bends the outermost (extreme) fibers are
compressed along the top edge. And at the same time, fibers
stretch along the bottom edge. The outermost (extreme) wood
fibers on the top and bottom surfaces are stressed more than
those fibers in the middle. An Fb value indicates design strength
for those extreme fibers. The higher the Fb the stronger the
wood.
- Lumber grade. A higher
grade of a given species has a higher strength rating (Fb) and
often has a higher stiffness value (E) too.
- Species of wood. All
species are not created equal. For example southern pine is
much stronger and stiffer than spruce.
- Duration of load.
How long will the members be loaded? Full-time loading (floor
joists) serves as the benchmark value. Benchmark values are
multiplied by 1.15 to yield snow-load values and by 1.25 for
7-day loading. Don't worry about the calculations! Tables automatically
handle this adjustment. You just read the numbers under the
appropriate column heading. For example: A select structural,
southern pine 2x8 floor joist has a 2650 Fb. While the same
grade and species 2x8 has a 3040 Fb when used as a roof rafter
in snow country. E values are unaffected by duration of load.
What You Need
Alright, so
now you want to use this information. First you need to get a few
things: Code book; AF&PA's Span
Tables for Joists and Rafters (this assigns allowable spans
to various combinations of E and Fb); and a copy of Design
Values for Joists and Rafters (this has Fb and E values
for various species, sizes and grades of dimension lumber).
The code book
can be purchased through your local code official. Building codes
provide you with information about required grades, spans, bearing,
lateral support, notching, etc. Purchase ICC,
International
Residential Code, 5203 Leesburg Pike, Suite 708, Falls Church,
VA 22041. CABO is referenced in most local building codes as an
acceptable option to the local code. This code book has one appendix
with span tables for joists and rafters and another with design
values for joists and rafters.
These documents
provide an expanded view of span-table use through "explanation"
and "commentary" sections at the beginning and end of the publications.
I find the AWC documents easy to follow. The technical staff at
AWC is eager and able to help you understand the documents if you
get stuck. You can contact the AWC Helpdesk at 1-202-463-4713 or
via email at awcinfo@afandpa.org.
Or visit their website at http://www.awc.org
for more information.
There are other
span tables and publications available too. The following are links
to several online span tables:
Canadian
Wood Council Span Calculator
Southern
Forest Products Association Span Tables
Western
Wood Products Association Span Tables.
PULLING
IT ALL TOGETHER
Calculating
Loads
For the most
part, live load and dead load values for floor and roof systems
are considered distributed loads. In other words, the weight is
distributed or shared uniformly by the members in the floor or roof
system. In order to establish proper sizes, grades and on-center
spacing of joists and rafters you first need to determine what loading
is acceptable to the building code.
Use your code
book here. Look up the allowable loads and deflection limits imposed
by your local code. For example: the International Residential
Code includes the following information.
Floors & Ceilings (joists)
| Dwellings |
live load (psf) |
dead load |
| Rooms other than sleeping rooms |
40 |
* |
| Sleeping rooms |
30 |
* |
| Attics with storage |
20 |
* |
* weights listed in code book appendix
Deflection
The code section
on allowable deflection of structural members indicates that the
deflection shall not be greater than L/360 for floors and plastered
construction; L/180 for rafters having slopes greater than 3/12
with no finished ceiling attached to rafters; and L/240 for all
other structural members. So these are the limits set by the code.
You can also
use AF&PA's Span
Tables for Joists and Rafters. This is the easiest way to
determine allowable dead loads, live loads and deflection limits.
This publication has a much more extensive offering of possible
joist and rafter conditions.
Once you find
the appropriate table in the book, you determine acceptable Fb
and E values for your particular span condition. Span is the distance
from face to face of the supports. (for joists: from basement-side
of sill to sill-side of center girder.)
Rafters
Rafters are
sized the same way as joists: Establish live load, dead load and
deflection limits; use the appropriate rafter table to determine
acceptable Fb and E values; and then select the appropriate
species, size and grade from AF&PA's Design
Values for Joists and Rafters publication.
Sizing rafters
differs from sizing joists in 2 ways:
1) The span
of a rafter is not based on the measurement along its length. Rather,
the span is based on the rafter's "horizontal projection". This
is the horizontal distance from the inside surface of the supporting
wall to the inside surface of the ridge board. So consider a simple
gable roof on a 24-foot wide ranch framed with 2x6 exterior walls
and a 1 1/2 ridge: the span would be 11'5 3/4".
2) You must
determine the snow load for your region. This information is found
in the code book. The snow load is treated as a live load when you
use AF&PA's tables. If your code book says your snow load is
40 psf, then you use the 40 psf live load rafter table. The fact
that snow loads only act part of the year has been used to create
the rafter tables.
Compression
Perpendicular to the Grain
The loads carried
by floor joists, ceiling joists and rafters are transferred through
their end points to supporting walls and beams. The ends of these
members must be able to "react" or resist these loads without crushing.
AF&PA lists the required compression perpendicular to grain
values for joists and rafters for various spans, on-center spacing
and loading conditions in its Span
Tables for Joists and Rafters. AF&PA's Design
Values for Joists and Rafters lists compression perpendicular
to grain design values for a variety of species. Just be sure the
species design value exceeds the required compression perpendicular
to grain value for your structural condition.
SUMMARY
Step
by Step
Here is a checklist
of steps to follow when using span tables
1) check plans
to determine span and on-center spacing (design conditions)
2) check codes for allowable live load,
snow load, dead load and deflection
3) select appropriate span table
4) match span in table to design condition
and determine minimum Fb and E values listed in the span
table
- NOTE: you will have
options for on-center spacing and size
5) select appropriate species
and grade from values listed in design values table
- NOTE: you will have
options regarding species and grade providing you with an economic
opportunity
6) determine required compression
perpendicular to grain design value in table
7) verify that the compression perpendicular
to grain design value for the species selected in step 5 meets the
required design value determined in step 6
EXAMPLE:
A Test Case
Test your skill.
Let's work through an example that illustrates the steps involved
in using the tables. Let's say you're building a 16-foot addition
and have to select the correct size and species of lumber for the
floor joists. The joists will be 16 inches on-center. Their design
span, the exact length from face to face of the supports, is 15
feet 1 inch (see illustration - Figure 1)
Figure 1
When sizing joists, use the clear
span - the length from support to support - not the full length
of the joist.
Steps
Floor
Joists
Step 1 Check
The Code: First check the local code for allowable live load,
dead load, and deflection (see Figure #2). For this example I'll
use the ICC International
Residential Code , which serves as the model for many state
and local codes. This sets an allowable first-floor live load of
40 psf, a dead load of 10 psf, and a deflection of L/360.
Figure 2
Live loads and deflection limits
are set by code. These tables are from the ICC International
Residential Code.
|
MINIMUM UNIFORMLY DISTRIBUTED LIVE LOADS |
| Use |
Live Load |
| Balconies (exterior) |
60 |
| Decks |
40 |
| Fire escapes |
40 |
| Garages (passenger cars only) |
50 |
| Attics (no storage with roof slope no steeper
than 3 in 12) |
10 |
| Attics (limited attic storage) |
20 |
| Rooms (except sleeping rooms) |
40 |
| Sleeping Rooms |
30 |
| Stairs |
40 |
| |
|
|
ALLOWABLE DEFLECTION OF STRUCTURAL MEMBERS |
| Structural Member |
Allowable Deflection |
| Rafters with slope > 3/12 and no ceiling
attached |
L/180 |
| Interior walls and partitions |
H/180 |
| Floors and plastered ceilings |
L/360 |
| All other structural members |
L/240 |
| |
|
| Notes: L = span length, H = vertical
span |
Step
2 Span Table: Select the appropriate
table in Span
Tables for Joists and Rafters . The Table of contents indicates
that Table F-2 matches these loading conditions. Using Table F-2
(Figure #3), check each lumber size to see if a 16-inch spacing
will permit a span of 15 feet 1 inch. Start with the "16.0" line
in the "Spacing" column at the left of the table, then go to the
right until you reach an appropriate span at least 15 feet 1 inch
in this case). Then drop down to find the appropriate Fb value for
the span.
As the table
shows, no 2x8's meet the span and spacing requirements, but a 2x10
with an E of 1,300,000 psi and Fb of 1093 psi can span 15 feet 3
inches - more than enough. A 2x12 with an E of 800,000 psi and Fb
of 790 psi also works, since it can span 15 feet and 10 inches.
Figure 3
Given a design span of 15 feet 1
inch and a 16 inch joist spacing, first determine which size lumber
will work. Then find the required Fb value at the bottom
of the column.
|
FLOOR JOISTS WITH L/360 DEFLECTION LIMITS |
DESIGN CRITERIA:
Deflection - For 40 PSF live load.
Limited to span in inches divided by 360.
Strength - Live load of 40 psf plus dead load of 10 psf determines
the required bending design value. |
Joist Size
(in.) |
Spacing
(in.) |
Modulus of Elasticity, E, in 1,000,000
psi |
| 0.8 |
0.9 |
1.0 |
1.1 |
1.2 |
1.3 |
1.4 |
1.5 |
1.6 |
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
| 2x6 |
12.0 |
8-6 |
8-10 |
9-2 |
9-6 |
9-9 |
10-0 |
10-3 |
10-6 |
10-9 |
| 16.0 |
7-9 |
8-0 |
8-4 |
8-7 |
8-10 |
9-1 |
9-4 |
9-6 |
9-9 |
| 19.2 |
7-3 |
7-7 |
7-10 |
8-1 |
8-4 |
8-7 |
8-9 |
9-0 |
9-2 |
| 24.0 |
6-9 |
7-0 |
7-3 |
7-6 |
7-9 |
7-11 |
8-2 |
8-4 |
8-6 |
| 2x8 |
12.0 |
11-3 |
11-8 |
12-1 |
12-6 |
12-10 |
13-2 |
13-6 |
13-10 |
14-2 |
| 16.0 |
10-2 |
10-7 |
11-0 |
11-4 |
11-8 |
12-0 |
12-3 |
12-7 |
12-10 |
| 19.2 |
9-7 |
10-0 |
10-4 |
10-8 |
11-0 |
11-3 |
11-7 |
11-10 |
12-1 |
| 24.0 |
8-11 |
9-3 |
9-7 |
9-11 |
10-2 |
10-6 |
10-9 |
11-0 |
11-3 |
| 2x10 |
12.0 |
14-4 |
14-11 |
15-5 |
15-11 |
16-5 |
16-10 |
17-3 |
17-8 |
18-0 |
| 16.0 |
13-0 |
13-6 |
14-0 |
14-6 |
14-11 |
15-3 |
15-8 |
16-0 |
16-5 |
| 19.2 |
12-3 |
12-9 |
13-2 |
13-7 |
14-0 |
14-5 |
14-9 |
15-1 |
15-5 |
| 24.0 |
11-4 |
11-10 |
12-3 |
12-8 |
13-0 |
13-4 |
13-8 |
14-0 |
14-4 |
| 2x12 |
12.0 |
17-5 |
18-1 |
18-9 |
19-4 |
19-11 |
20-6 |
21-0 |
21-6 |
21-11 |
| 16.0 |
15-10 |
16-5 |
17-0 |
17-7 |
18-1 |
18-7 |
19-1 |
19-6 |
19-11 |
| 19.2 |
14-11 |
15-6 |
16-0 |
16-7 |
17-0 |
17-6 |
17-11 |
18-4 |
18-9 |
| 24.0 |
13-10 |
14-4 |
14-11 |
15-4 |
15-10 |
16-3 |
16-8 |
17-0 |
17-5 |
Fb
Fb
Fb
Fb |
12.0 |
718 |
777 |
833 |
888 |
941 |
993 |
1043 |
1092 |
1140 |
| 16.0 |
790 |
855 |
917 |
977 |
1036 |
1093 |
1148 |
1202 |
1255 |
| 19.2 |
840 |
909 |
975 |
1039 |
1101 |
1161 |
1220 |
1277 |
1333 |
| 24.0 |
905 |
979 |
1050 |
1119 |
1186 |
1251 |
1314 |
1376 |
1436 |
| Note: The required bending design
value, Fb, in pounds per square inch is shown at
the bottom of each table and is applicable to all lumber sizes
shown. Spans are shown in feet - inches and are limited to
26' and less. Check sourcesof supply for availability of lumber
in lengths greater than 20'. |
| EXCERPTED FROM SPAN TABLES
FOR JOISTS AND RAFTERS, Copyright © 1993 AMERICAN
FOREST & PAPER ASSN., WASHINGTON, D.C. |
Step 3 Wood
Design Values: Now you must select a wood species and grade
that meets the required Fb and E values, and that's available
in your area. For this, use the tables in Design
Values for Joists and Rafters. For this example, I've excerpted
the relevant sections from tables for hem-fir, Douglas fir-larch,
and spruce-pine-fir (Figure 4). In hem-fir, either a No.1 2x10 or
a No. 2 2x12 would work. In Douglas fir-larch, either a No. 2 2x10
or a No. 2 2x12 works. In spruce-pine-fir, No. 1/No. 2 2x10 or 2x12
would do the job.
Figure 4
After determining what size lumber
to use, turn to the tables in Design Values For Joists
and Rafters to select a species and grade that meets the required
Fb and E values. The tables shown here are excerpts from
the hem-fir, Douglas fir-larch, and spruce-pine-fir tables.
DESIGN VALUES FOR JOISTS AND RAFTERS
VISUALLY GRADED LUMBER |
| These Fb values for
use where repetative members are spaced not more than 24 inches.
For wider spacing, the Fb values shall be reduced
13%. Values for surfaced dry or surfaced green lumber apply
at 19% maximum moisture content in use. |
| Species and Grade |
Size |
Design Value in Bending (Fb) |
Modulus of Elasticity (E) |
| Normal Duration |
Snow Loading |
7 Day Loading |
| HEM-FIR |
| Select Structural |
2x10 |
1770 |
2035 |
2215 |
1,600,000 |
| No. 1 & Btr. |
1330 |
1525 |
1660 |
1,500,000 |
| No. 1 |
1200 |
1380 |
1500 |
1,500,000 |
| No. 2 |
1075 |
1235 |
1345 |
1,300,000 |
| No. 3 |
635 |
725 |
790 |
1,200,000 |
| Select Structural |
2x12 |
1610 |
1850 |
2015 |
1,600,000 |
| No. 1 & Btr. |
1210 |
1390 |
1510 |
1,500,000 |
| No. 1 |
1095 |
1255 |
1365 |
1,500,000 |
| No. 2 |
980 |
1125 |
1385 |
1,300,000 |
| No. 3 |
575 |
660 |
720 |
1,200,000 |
| DOUGLAS FIR-LARCH |
| Select Structural |
2x10 |
1835 |
2110 |
2295 |
1,900,000 |
| No. 1 & Btr. |
1455 |
1675 |
1820 |
1,800,000 |
| No. 1 |
1265 |
1455 |
1580 |
1,700,000 |
| No. 2 |
1105 |
1275 |
1385 |
1,600,000 |
| No. 3 |
635 |
725 |
790 |
1,400,000 |
| Select Structural |
2x12 |
1670 |
1920 |
2085 |
1,900,000 |
| No. 1 & Btr. |
1325 |
1520 |
1655 |
1,800,000 |
| No. 1 |
1150 |
1325 |
1440 |
1,700,000 |
| No. 2 |
1005 |
1155 |
1260 |
1,600,000 |
| No. 3 |
575 |
660 |
720 |
1,400,000 |
| SPRUCE-PINE-FIR |
| Select Structural |
2x10 |
1580 |
1820 |
1975 |
1,500,000 |
| No. 1/No. 2 |
1105 |
1275 |
1385 |
1,400,000 |
| No. 3 |
635 |
725 |
790 |
1,200,000 |
| Select Structural |
2x12 |
1440 |
1655 |
1795 |
1,500,000 |
| No. 1/No. 2 |
1005 |
1155 |
1260 |
1,400,000 |
| No. 3 |
575 |
660 |
720 |
1,200,000 |
| EXCERPTED FROM DESIGN VALUES
FOR JOISTS AND RAFTERS, Copyright © 1992 AMERICAN
FOREST & PAPER ASSN., WASHINGTON, D.C. |
Step
4 Bearing Check: The final step is to
make sure the lumber you've chosen meets the required design value
for compression perpendicular to the grain. The loads carried by
floor joists, ceiling joists, and rafters are transferred through
their end points to supporting walls and beams. The ends of these
members must be able to resist these loads without crushing.
Table 9.1 in
Span Tables
for Joists and Rafters (Figure 5) gives a required compression
value of 237 psi for a span of 16 feet and bearing length of 1.5
inches. (the tables permit a bearing length of up to 3.5 inches,
but since 1.5 is probably the worst case that you'll encounter for
joist or rafter bearing, it's a safe value.) You can get the compression
perpendicular to grain design value for various species selected
from the addendum that comes with Design
Values for Joists and Rafters. For instance, hem-fir has
an acceptable value of 405 psi, spruce-pine-fir of 425 psi.
Figure 5
Check to see that the lumber species
selected has the necessary compression strength perpendicular to
the grain. This table, from Span Tables for Joists and Rafters,
gives the required values for various design conditions; an addendum
that comes with Design Values for Joists and Rafters gives
the valies for specific species.
|
SPAN TABLES FOR JOISTS AND RAFTERS |
| Required compression perpendicular
to grain values (Fcperp) in pounds per square inch
for simple span joists and rafters with uniform loads |
|
Bearing Length, in. |
| Span, ft. |
1.5 |
2.0 |
2.5 |
3.0 |
3.5 |
| 8 |
119 |
98 |
71 |
59 |
51 |
| 10 |
148 |
111 |
89 |
74 |
63 |
| 12 |
178 |
133 |
107 |
89 |
76 |
| 14 |
207 |
156 |
124 |
104 |
89 |
| 16 |
237 |
178 |
142 |
119 |
102 |
| 18 |
267 |
200 |
160 |
133 |
114 |
| 20 |
296 |
222 |
178 |
148 |
127 |
| 22 |
326 |
244 |
196 |
163 |
140 |
| 24 |
356 |
267 |
213 |
178 |
152 |
Notes:
1) Bearing width is assumed to be 1.5"
2) Total uniform load is assumed to be 66.67 plf.
3) Alternate Fcperp values were possible by adjusting
the tabulated values in direct proportion to the desired load. |
|
1993 ADDENDUM TO DESIGN VALUES FOR
JOISTS AND RAFTERS |
|
Species1 |
Compression perpendicular to grain design
value, psi. (Fcperp) |
| Douglas Fir-Larch |
625 |
| Eastern White Pine |
350 |
| Hem-Fir |
405 |
| Southern Pine, Dense |
660 |
| Southern Pine, Select Structural
No.1, No.2, No.3, Stud, Construction, Standard, Utility |
565 |
| Southern Pine, Non-Dense |
480 |
| Spruce-Pine-Fir |
425 |
| Spruce-Pine-Fir (south) |
335 |
| 1. Design values apply to all
grades for the species listed unless otherwise indicated in
the table above. |
| EXCERPTED FROM SPAN TABLES
FOR JOISTS AND RAFTERS, Copyright © 1993 AMERICAN
FOREST & PAPER ASSN., WASHINGTON, D.C. |
Ceiling
Joists and Rafters
Ceiling joists
are sized like floor joists except that deflection limits vary depending
on whether the joists will be used for attic storage or will have
a plaster or drywall finish. Check your code and follow the AF&PA
tables accordingly.
When using
the tables to size rafters, there are two points to keep in mind.
First, remember that the rafter's span is not its actual length,
but its total horizontal projection (see Figure 6). Second, use
the snow load value for your region in determining which rafter
table to use. If your code book says your snow load is 40 psf, then
you must use the 40 psf live load rafter table. The fact that snow
loads only act part of the year has been taken into account in the
rafter tables, but don't forget to use the "Snow Loading" column
to get the Fb design value.
Figure 6
Use the horizontal projection
of a rafter, not its actual length, when figuring rafter span.